When mindfulness meditation might do more harm than good


You’ve probably heard the advice that mindfulness meditation isn’t recommended for people with depression. But what’s the real story behind this warning?

I wanted to share some insights on this complex topic because, honestly, the answer isn’t black and white.

Why mindfulness can sometimes backfire

First, there’s a practical issue: depression often reduces our ability to concentrate and our energy levels, both essential for mindfulness practices. While you can start with very short sessions, struggling with focus can reinforce negative self-talk.

More importantly, mindfulness invites us to turn our attention inward. But when you’re depressed, your inner landscape isn’t exactly sunshine and rainbows. Shining a spotlight on unpleasant symptoms and dark thoughts can trigger a negative spiral or amplify those difficult emotions.

It can also force you to confront emotions and thoughts you’re not yet equipped to handle, especially when you don’t have the energy or strength to process them effectively.

Studies suggest that in some cases of severe depression or anxiety, mindfulness practices can actually worsen symptoms.

But here’s the nuance: it’s only in some cases.

Mindfulness can be incredibly effective when combined with other forms of therapy. There’s even a specific approach called Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy (MBCT) designed to help manage faulty thought patterns and rumination (that exhausting cycle of getting stuck in the same unhelpful thoughts).

Research shows mindfulness works particularly well for depression linked to chronic pain and for various anxiety disorders.

My personal experience

I live with generalized anxiety, and I’ve noticed that while mindfulness helps me long-term, during acute anxiety episodes, it actually makes things worse. It makes me hyper-aware of my anxious thoughts, and I can’t seem to break free from them. During crises, I find it more helpful to redirect my attention to something completely external, like a distraction, to break the spiral. Then I can return to my practice with more perspective.

One beautiful benefit of mindfulness is that it helps you catch the early warning signs of depressive or anxiety episodes. You learn to recognize thought patterns as they emerge and can pause before boarding that train.

The bottom line

It depends. It depends on the person, the type of depression, and where you are in your mental health journey.

Through my six years studying psychology and working with clients facing mental health challenges, I’ve seen how individual this process can be. If you’re considering mindfulness while dealing with depression, it’s crucial to be aware of these risks and ideally work with a professional who understands them.

And most importantly: if mindfulness makes your symptoms worse or simply isn’t a pleasant experience, don’t hesitate to stop and seek other forms of support.

Take care of yourself,

Om, peace 🧡

Clem

Clémence Dieryck

I'm a bilingual yoga teacher who helps people who sit a lot gain mobility, move without pain and reduce their stress.

Read more from Clémence Dieryck

I used to love posting spectacular yoga poses on social media. You probably know the ones I'm talking about: arm balances, deep splits... the poses that make people go "wow". Then I realised that it was going against everything I stand for. These images were sending the wrong message: that yoga isn't for everyone. That you need to be fit, healthy, flexible and strong to practice. Yoga is for everyone. But not everything is for everyone. Most of my clients come to me precisely because they're...

I've been reflecting on a question that keeps coming up in my coaching practice: should we lean into our natural tendencies or push ourselves beyond them? As often happens, the answer is: a bit of both. Let me share what I mean. I recently talked with my niece Manon, who struggles with maths but constantly compares herself to her naturally gifted brother. For her, forcing herself into a maths-heavy career would mean working twice as hard for half the results. She'd be fighting an uphill...

It’s not always easy to motivate yourself to move on a regular day, but when it’s 35°C… Yet it’s still just as important to take care of yourself and your body. So how do we do it? Well, we adapt! Yoga is for the morning! Today, I did yoga with one of my clients at 8:00, when it was still “only” 23°C, and it was divine. We did just enough movement to energize and relax before what promised to be an intense day. It reminded me how important it is to adapt our practice to the season. If you...